Grant Information

ENDOPHYTES AS SOURCES OF ANTIMICROBIALS TO CONTROL HUANGLONGBING (HLB)

Sponsoring Institution National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Program ECDRE - Emergency Citrus Disease Research and Extension Program
Status ACTIVE
Funding Source OTHER GRANTS
Division FLAW
Reporting Frequency Annual
Project Director Shetty, K.
Accession Number 1029427
Grant Number 2022-70029-38526
Project Number FLAW-2022-06729
Agreement Number 2022-70029-38526
Proposal Number 2022-06729
Dates 2022-09-15 - 2025-09-14
Grant Year 2022
Cumulative Award Amount $500,000.00
Animal Health Component 100%
Recipient Organization FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY

MIAMI,FL 33199
Keywords antimicrobials
candidatus liberibacter asiaticus
citrus greening
clas
endophytes
viability qpcr
Research Effort Applied (100%)
Basic (0%)
Developmental (0%)
Classification Parameters
Knowledge AreaSubject of InvestigationField of SciencePercent
215 - Biological Control of Pests Affecting Plants 999 - Citrus, general/other 1160 - Pathology 100%
Non-technical Summary

Huanglongbing (HLB), also known as citrus greening is the most devastating citrus diseases in the U.S. HLB is caused by the bacterium Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus (CLas) and is transmitted by a tiny insect, called the Asian citrus psyllid. Since HLB was detected in Florida in 2005, Florida's citrus production has fallen by 75%. The disease also threatens other citrus producing states. There is no cure for HLB, effective disease prevention and treatment methods have proven elusive. There is a high priority need for developing anti-microbial treatments that could reverse the disease impacts, specifically by reducing bacterial inoculum in infected citrus trees. The project proposes to first purify and characterize active anti-CLas compounds derived from bacterial endophytes isolated from survivor citrus trees. Next, uptake and anti-CLas activity within the citrus root system will be evaluated using CLas-citrus hairy root bio-assay. Finally, the protective and curative effects of purified antimicrobial compound treatment against CLas will be demonstrated under greenhouse conditions. Promising results from the project can readily be translated into products for the benefit of stakeholders through the agency of Marrone Bio Innovations, Inc. Initial information about the project will be shared with growers, promising results will be shared with growers through seminars, extension website, social media, newsletters, etc.

Goals / Objectives

This research project is designed to fast-track the discovery and development of novel anti-CLas natural compounds with unique mode of action so that the citrus growers can have diverse, effective HLB prevention and mitigation tools. This two-year project would comprise four main objectives:

  1. Extract, fractionate, purify, and characterize most active anti-CLas components from selected endophytes
  2. Pre-screen most active component/s for Anti-CLas activity using CLas hairy root assay
  3. Evaluate protective and curative effects of purified antimicrobial compound/s treatment against CLas under greenhouse conditions
  4. Stakeholder outreach and engagement at different stages of the project through cooperative extension
Methods (unparsed)

(Obj. 1) To identify compounds that are responsible for the anti-CLas activity found during the previous work (psyllid homogenate assay) we will use a bioassay-guided fractioning and purification scheme. we will analyze the crude extract using GCMS and UHLPC-MS/MS to identify the major groups of compounds found in the extracts. After, we will start initial fractioning of the crude extracts using C18 solid phase separation. This will yield four fractions based on the compound's polarity, the anti-CLas activity of these fractions will be tested once more. The most active fraction will be further separated via Automated Flash Chromatography paired with an ELSD detector. Each of the fractions obtained via flash chromatography will be teste once more for anti-CLas activity. If the chromatography yields more than 20 fractions, some of the fractions will be "pooled" together. Biologically active fractions will be analyzed via UHPLC-MS/MS to determine their composition. If multiple compounds are present, preparative HPLC will be performed. Pure compound fractions will be analyzed and identified via Fourier Transform Ion Cyclotron Resonance (FT-ICR) and Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR). (Obj. 2) We will utilize the CLas-citrus hairy root bioassays to evaluate the efficacy of anti-CLas active fraction derived from endophytic bacteria and determine their inhibitory activity against CLas within the citrus root tissue. CLas-citrus hairy root cultures are periodically subjected to multiple quality control diagnostics to confirm and quantify CLas titers within the hairy root cultures. Next, the CLas-citrus hairy root cultures will be treated with the respective fraction/s, at multiple dosages (2%, 5%, 10% v/v), using the in vitro multi-well plate format, alongside untreated and DMSO/solvent alone controls. All the treatments are vacuum infiltrated to facilitate the penetration into the hairy root matrices and incubated for 72 hours. The hairy root tissues are subsequently sampled for molecular diagnostics. The effectiveness of the treatments will be determined by estimating relative CLas titers among the controls and treatments by qPCR amplification of ribonucleotide reductase β-subunit gene marker of CLas (RNR/nrdB, RNR-F/RNR-R). (Obj. 3) The most promising pure compound/s found to have activity against CLas in the CLas-ctirus hairy root assay will be tested in planta. We plan to test the compound/s on nursery trees that are approximately 1 year from budding. Scion and rootstock will depend on what is available from nurseries 3 to 6 months prior to initiation of the greenhouse studies but we will aim for sweet orange scions like 'Valencia'. Common rootstocks include 'Swingle' citrumelo, X-639, Cleopatra mandarin, and US-897. Two types of trials will be undertaken: 1) to determine the curative effect of compounds and 2) to determine the protective effect of compounds. Whether a compound is tested for a curative or protective effect will depend on the results from previous analysis and the likely mode of action. To investigate whether there is a curative effect on CLas in planta, trees will be inoculated with CLas by grafting 4 months prior to trial initiation with budwood that is known to contain active populations of CLas. The trees will be tested monthly after graft inoculation to confirm whether they have become CLas positive. Only trees that are confirmed CLas positive will be used in the trial. The compounds will be applied one of three ways, spray application, soil drenching, or possibly via injection. Soil uptake will be evaluated by seedling assay where 6-month-old seedlings in containers will be drenched with the compounds and the foliage tested to see if the compound can be detected. Similarly, the concentration range will also be determined prior to starting the greenhouse trial based on experiments with HLB-affected cuttings. These cuttings will contain one angular stem node with a leaf attached of approximately 10 cm in length. The cuttings will be placed in tubes containing a solution of the compound at multiple concentrations for 48 hours. The cuttings will then be transferred to water for a week. After a week they will be tested for the presence of live CLas cells with the RNA-based CLas viability assay. In the greenhouse experiment. there will be a minimum of five trees per treatment and preferably there should be 10. The leaf titer of CLas and viability will be taken at the time 0 just before the applications and 2 weeks, 4 weeks and 4 months post-application from two newly mature leaves per tree. At 6 months, the trees will be harvested. The total leaf area, trunk diameter, root mass, dry weight will be collected along with a disease rating. The titer will be measured in the leaves and roots. Two control treatments will be included in each trial, an untreated CLas inoculated and an untreated uninoculated control. The protective trial will be very similar with the exception of the inoculation timing to the compound application. In this case, the compound will be applied 2 to 3 weeks prior to inoculation with CLas. The trees will be monitored for CLas titer. The number of repetitions will need to be larger as there is a probability that some trees will not become CLas positive. The statistical analysis will be conducted with generalized linear mixed model methods and the distributions used will be dependent on the data. (Obj. 4) We understand outreach and extension of the project results to citrus growers is a key component and will be executed by all PIs. Members of the project team will communicate with stakeholders to identify needs and obstacles through surveys and grower forums. It is also essential to disseminate information rapidly as it arises from this proposed research. This will be accomplished efficiently via websites, presentations at industry and scientific meetings as well as through our stakeholder members. The information will be shared through regular dissemination of research reports, blogs, webinars (i.e., www.citrusresearch.ifas.ufl.edu), and participation in UF/IFAS hosted podcasts and newsletters focused on citrus. Findings and recommendations from this project will be conveyed to growers using these and other resources. Recommendations will be quickly delivered through multiple extension events through posters, displays, and handouts. Dissemination of information is also expected to take place via peer-reviewed scientific journals, extension publications, trade periodicals, oral presentations at field days held at the project sites, citrus industry events, professional society meetings, and citrus industry governing board meetings to be determined.

Project Timeline Tracking

Outputs

Target Audience
U.S. Citrus growers, U.S. citrus industry, Extension agents, Pesticide and Ag. biologicals industry, HLB research scientists, USDA-NIFA

Changes / Problems
Regrettably, the progress on isolation of pure active compounds has been very slow due to technical reasons and challenges with our personnel. On the technical side, the nature of the target compounds has made challenging their isolation using standard approaches, both silica and C18 columns do not seem to have enough separative power to produce pure quantities of the target compounds. Additionally, our equipment has had some issues that have further delayed our progress. On the personnel side, one of our FIU Co-PD moved to a different institution and the graduate student in charge of developing the isolation protocols has had some family-related leaves.

Training & Professional Development
One doctoral student (fellowship supported by another USDA grant) and threeundergraduate students. The project has provided research training and mentoring opportunities to a Hispanic minority undergraduate student and technician. The students and staff were routinely mentored by the PI in laboratory techniques and scientific inquiry.

Dissemination Streams
Project updates and results were periodically disseminated to the team members, as well as to stakeholders in TX, FL, and CA, and the broader scientific/citrus stakeholder community through publications, regional and national news outlets directly and indirectly through FIU news article and FIU Agroecology Program website.

Next Reporting Steps
In the next reporting period, FIU lab will focus on completing the isolation and characterization of target metabolites. We will also supply our collaborators with 95% pure active compound for lab and greenhouse-based experimental evaluations. At UF we are waiting for the anti-CLas components to conduct our greenhouse and cutting assays. We will hopefully be ready to go with inoculated and CLas-infected trees. The testing for CLas titer in December 2024 will let us know how soon we can proceed with the assays. The active metabolites will also be evaluated first for anti-CLas activity in citrus using hairy root assays (TAMU), where CLas is being co-cultured/maintained in citrus-derived hairy roots, and finally in planta activity in greenhouse studies

Outputs

Target Audience
U.S. Citrus growers, U.S. citrus industry, Extension agents, Pesticide and Ag. biologicals industry, HLB research scientists, USDA-NIFA

Changes / Problems
The first assays were very inconsistent due to variations in the raw extract. After some experimentation, these issues were identified as problems with the significant ingredients of the growth media. The significant challenges to isolating the active compounds are the complexity of the original growth media and subsequent extracts. The media used to culture the endophytes are rich in carbohydrate proteins and contain many secondary metabolites that do not derive from the endophytes but come from the complex components used for the "broth". The project also slowed down significantly because of the need to remove large quantities of water from the raw extracts (48-72 hours of freeze-drying per batch).

Training & Professional Development
Nothing Reported

Dissemination Streams
Team members were actively engaged in preparing project summaries and topics related to our citrus stakeholders in TX, FL, and CA. These were prepared and disseminated through regional and national news outlets directly and indirectly through FIU news article and FIU Agroecology Program website. Attendees: World wide web "Scientists believe weapon against citrus greening already exists in nature" FIU News, February 1, 2023 https://news.fiu.edu/2023/scientists-believe-weapon-against-citrus-greening-already-exists-in-nature Team members published a Research Snapshot that is available for download on the Science for Citrus Health website. Attendees: World wide web Kateel G. Shetty (2023). Endophytes as sources of antimicrobials to control Huanglongbing (HLB) UC Agriculture and Natural Resources - Science for Citrus Health - Research Snapshots https://ucanr.edu/sites/scienceforcitrushealth/Research_Snapshots/https___ucanr.edu_sites_scienceforcitrushealth_Research_Snapshots_NIFA_I_938_/Shetty1/ Team members organized and presented a citrus greening workshop/symposium at the citrus greening workshops/symposiums at the 2023 Annual Meeting (2023) of the American Phytopathological Society-Caribbean Division (APS-CD) at South Padre Island. Attendees: ~60. https://www.apsnet.org/members/community/divisions/carib/Pages/MeetingHistory.aspx Team members organized and presented in multiple sessions of the 2nd Congress of the International Society for Citrus Huanglongbing and Phloem-Colonizing Bacterial Pathosystems (IS-CHPP), October 25-28, Clearwater Beach, FL. Attendees: ~100 https://crec.ifas.ufl.edu/ISCHPP/ Team members also participated actively in various citrus growers' and organizations' meetings (e.g., Texas Citrus Pest and Disease Management Corporation, Texas Citrus Mutual, and TAMUK-Citrus Center), where the citrus project activities/updates were periodically updated to the stakeholders.

Next Reporting Steps
We are making progress towards isolating single compounds, escalating the isolation procedure, and characterizing the active metabolites. The active metabolites will be evaluated first for anti-CLas activity in citrus using hairy root assays (TAMU), where CLas is being co-cultured/maintained in citrus-derived hairy roots, and finally in planta activity in greenhouse studies (UF). <br><br>

Impacts (unparsed)

<br>What was accomplished under these goals? The major goals of the project are to: (1) Extract, fractionate, purify, and characterize most active anti-CLas components from selected endophytic bacteria (FIU); (2) Pre-screen most active component/s for Anti-CLas activity using citrus CLas hairy root assay (TAMU); (3) Evaluate protective and curative effects of purified antimicrobial compound/s treatment against CLas under greenhouse conditions (UF); and (4) Stakeholder outreach and engagement at different stages of the project through cooperative extension (UF, TAMU, FIU) At FIU the focus was on objective 1 geared towards (1a) Isolating the active compounds (or compounds) present in the endophyte extracts, (1b) Scaling the isolation procedure of this compound to purify quantities that could allow experimental manipulation of live plants, (1c) Identifying and characterizing the active compounds in the extract. During the year-1 of the project following objectives/activities supported by the grant were accomplished. Our approach uses a bioassay-guided fractionation scheme combining liquid-liquid extraction and reverse and normal phase flash chromatography. Based on the initial trials, it was realized that the active compound is highly polar and cannot be extracted from the aqueous broth media using an organic solvent via direct liquid-liquid. Thus, the entire broth extract is processed by removing the protein (protein precipitation) and the water (Freeze Drying). The dry extract is reconstituted into 100% Methanol, and it is prepared for Dry-Loading using chromatography-grade silica at a ratio of 10:1. This silica is loaded into cartridges to be used for flash chromatography. In the initial step normal-phase chromatography (Silica with a two-solvent system: hexane and 3:1 Ethylacetate:2-propanol) was used to identify the significant fraction where the active compounds are present. We have narrowed down the activity of the extracts to two significant fractions. These fractions show 100% inhibition in the bioassays. <br><br><b>Publications</b><br>


Publications Inventory

Conference Papers and Presentations

Journal Articles