Grant Information

UNDERSTANDING BENEFICIAL AND PATHOGENIC MICROORGANISMS AND THEIR INTERACTIONS WITH EACH OTHER AND HOSTS TO CONTROL PLANT DISEASES

Sponsoring Institution National Institute of Food and Agriculture
Status COMPLETE
Funding Source HATCH
Division NIFA Formula
Reporting Frequency Annual
Project Director Borneman, James
Accession Number 1018010
Project Number CA-R-PPA-7774-H
Dates 2018-11-14 - 2023-09-30
Animal Health Component 33%
Performing Department Plant Pathology, Riverside
Recipient Organization UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, RIVERSIDE

RIVERSIDE,CA 92521
Keywords cyst nematodes
huanglongbing
metabolic models
suppressive soil
targeted antimicrobial peptides
Research Effort Applied (33%)
Basic (34%)
Developmental (33%)
Classification Parameters
Knowledge AreaSubject of InvestigationField of SciencePercent
212 - Pathogens and Nematodes Affecting Plants 999 - Citrus, general/other 1040 - Molecular biology 50%
212 - Pathogens and Nematodes Affecting Plants 1440 - Cole crops (includes cabbage, kale, broccoli, brussels sprouts, cauliflower, kohlrabi) 1040 - Molecular biology 25%
212 - Pathogens and Nematodes Affecting Plants 1440 - Cole crops (includes cabbage, kale, broccoli, brussels sprouts, cauliflower, kohlrabi) 1120 - Nematology 25%
Non-technical Summary

This project is to create new, more effective, and more sustainable strategies to manage a plant-parasitic nematode (sugarbeet cyst nematode). The sugarbeet cyst nematode causes considerable economic damage, affecting sugar beets and a wide range of other important crop plants such as broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cabbage, canola, cauliflower, kale, mustard, spinach, Swiss chard, radish, rapini, and others. This nematode has been reported to be among the most damaging plant-parasitic nematodes in the world. Current methods to control this nematode are inadequate, and therefore new management strategies are needed. Our project will endeavor to create new management strategies by determining the relationships between a beneficial fungus and the sugarbeet cyst nematode, and then using that information to manage the nematode. If our project is successful, it has the potential to be extended to other nematodes that cause large amounts of crop damage, including the soybean cyst nematode.This project is also to create new, more effective, and more sustainable strategies to manage huanglongbing (HLB) disease of citrus. HLB is the most devastating citrus disease that affects all types of citrus. Current methods to control HLB are inadequate, and therefore new management strategies are needed. Our approach is to use a harmless virus to deliver antimicrobial molecules to the citrus phloem, which is a part of the plumbing in a plant, and also the habitat of the bacterium that is believed to cause HLB. We will create our antimicrobial molecules by linking a peptide that blocks an essential CLas enzyme and a peptide that enables penetration into the putative HLB pathogen. Essential enzymes are those that, when blocked, will kill the organism. We have identified the essential enzymes of the putative HLB pathogen by creating and analyzing metabolic models of the putative HLB pathogen. This project is also to create and utilize an in silico metabolic model of HLB. Such models are mathematical representations of functioning cells. We expect that this approach will provide researchers, engineers and agribusinesses with a powerful suite of tools and an unprecedented base of knowledge - which we expect will enable them to create (i) molecules that kill the putative HLB pathogen, (ii) citrus trees that are resistant to HLB, and (iii) early HLB detection methods.

Goals / Objectives
  1. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Cyst Nematodes
    1. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils
    2. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode
    3. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Soils Suppressive Against Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode
    4. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode
  2. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Huanglongbing
    1. Create Peptides that Specifically Kill CLas with High Efficacy, and Test Them in Citrus by CTV Delivery and Engineered Plant Delivery
    2. Create and Utilize Metabolic Models of CLas, Citrus and ACP, and Their Interactions
    3. Identify Non-Pathogenic Microbes that Inhabit the Citrus Phloem, and Which Could be Used to Deliver Anti-CLas Agents to Manage Huanglongbing
  3. Develop New Methods for Molecular Microbial Ecology and Their Associated Bioinformatic Analyses
Methods (unparsed)

1a. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils1b. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Sugarbeet Cyst NematodeThis objective is to develop predictive models of the population dynamics between D. oviparasitica and H. schachtii in relation to the types of sugar beet cultivars, soil and D. oviparasitica. This will be accomplished by performing a series of greenhouse experiments using sugar beet field soils from the Imperial Valley that contain various amounts of D. oviparasitica.The sugar beet cultivars are those commonly used by Imperial Valley (CA) growers. The comparison of soils that have been autoclaved and not is a standard method enabling the determination of biological suppressiveness; if there are microorganisms that reduce H. schachtii population densities in a soil, such reductions will be observed in the non-autoclave soils compared to the autoclaved soil, both of which will be subsequently infested with H. schachtii as described below. In addition, our experiments will only examine soils that contain H. schachtii population densities that are above the economic damage threshold of 2 eggs/gram of soil (1), because this is when an organism like D. oviparasitica will be needed. To accomplish this, we will both enumerate the number of nematodes in each field soil as described above in RT2 and add H. schachtii J2 juveniles as described below. We will also include one control soil, which will be our H. schachtii suppressive 9E field soil located at the Agricultural Operations on the UC Riverside campus (2).Probit regression analyses will be used to develop predictive models, which will be used to develop new and more effective cropping decision models for sugar beet growers.1c. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Soils Suppressive Against Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode1d. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst NematodeWe will perform studies similar to those described in Objective 1a/1b above to complete these objectives.2a. Create Peptides that Specifically Kill CLas with High Efficacy, and Test Them in Citrus by CTV Delivery and Engineered Plant DeliveryTo identify the anti-CLas peptides for this sub-objective, we will perform in silico docking experiments using homology models of essential CLas enzymes. Homology models are built using existing structure models of related homologous proteins. We will construct and use homology models because crystal structures of CLas enzymes are not currently available. An example of a homology model that we constructed is the CLas serine/tyrosine phosphatase (STP) structure, which was built using the Swissmodel workspace. Supporting this approach, we demonstrated that homology models can be very effectively used in studies endeavoring to identify inhibitory molecules, because we used this CLas STP model to design molecules (C1 and C2) that effectively reduced CLas populations (unpublished). Finally, an amino acid sequence analysis determined that 12 of the aforementioned 82 essential CLas enzymes have related homologous proteins with an existing structure, which will enable us to build homology structure models. One example essential CLas enzyme is acetyl-CoA carboxylase, and the homology model we built for it is shown to the right. Given these results, we will be able to create homology models for 12 essential CLas enzymes, which will provide us with plenty of targets to successfully complete this sub-objective.2b. Create and Utilize Metabolic Models of CLas, Citrus and ACP, and Their InteractionsKarsten Zengler's group will build high-quality metabolic models for the three organisms involved in HLB: CLas, ACP, and citrus. Some of this research has been completed, as Zengler created metabolic models for six CLas strains and Liberibacter crescens (BT-1) (manuscript in preparation). To create the other two models, Zengler's group will follow the established protocol for reconstructing quality metabolic models (3).Because metabolic models are mathematical representations functional cells, and their interactions, they can be used for a myriad of important purposes. For example, a prominent feature of these models is the ability to analyze and contextualize omics datasets - e.g. all of the RNA transcripts that are expressed when a pathogen invades a host. This contextualization allows this dataset to be greatly expanded from just a list of RNA transcripts to include all of the other cellular reactions and pathways that are turned on or off under the conditions when that sample was collected. Contextualization of omics datasets can also reveal the molecular basis of the interactions between different organisms and the associated environmental conditions. It also enables one to predict phenotypes a priori.2c. Identify Non-Pathogenic Microbes that Inhabit the Citrus Phloem, and Which Could be Used to Deliver Anti-CLas Agents to Manage HuanglongbingWe have used an optimized phloem collection method involving scraping bark peels. Illumina sequence analyses have been used to identify several non-pathogenic bacteria that inhabit the phloem. To validate these prior findings, the next steps will include performing microscopic experiments (FISH) and adding tagged bacteria to citrus and tracking their movement.3. Develop New Methods for Molecular Microbial Ecology and Their Associated Bioinformatic AnalysesWe currently are adding new functionalities to our PRISE2 algorithm for PCR primer and probe design.REFERENCES CITED1. Cooke DA, Thomason IJ, McKinney HE, Bendixen WE, Hagemann RW. 1979. Chemical Control of Heterodera schachtii on Sugarbeet in California. J Nematol 11:205-6.2. Westphal A, Becker JO. 1999. Biological Suppression and Natural Population Decline of Heterodera schachtii in a California Field. Phytopathology 89:434-40.3. Thiele I, Palsson BØ. 2010. A protocol for generating a high-quality genome-scale metabolic reconstruction. Nature protocols 5:93.

Project Timeline Tracking

Outputs

Target Audience
This project has three interrelated objectives listed below.The target audiences for this project are (i) scientists endeavoring to perform similar studies targeting both similar and different pathogens, (ii) scientists performing molecular based studies that would benefit from the tools we have and are developing and (iii) stakeholders that could benefit from the solutions that are developed both directly and indirectly from our research.In addition, James Borneman integrates his research findings and related concepts into his undergraduate and graduate level microbiology courses, which he teaches every year: MCBL 126, an undergraduate microbiology course in microbiomes and MCBL 226, a graduate microbiology course in microbiomes. OBJECTIVE 1. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Cyst Nematodes OBJECTIVE 1a. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils OBJECTIVE 1b. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode OBJECTIVE 1c. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Soils Suppressive Against Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode OBJECTIVE 1d. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode OBJECTIVE 2. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Huanglongbing OBJECTIVE 2a. Create Peptides that Specifically Kill CLas with High Efficacy, and Test Them in Citrus by CTV Delivery and Engineered Plant Delivery OBJECTIVE 2b. Create and Utilize Metabolic Models of CLas, Citrus and ACP, and Their Interactions OBJECTIVE 2c. Identify Non-Pathogenic Microbes that Inhabit the Citrus Phloem, and Which Could be Used to Deliver Anti-CLas Agents to Manage Huanglongbing OBJECTIVE 3. Develop New Methods for Molecular Microbial Ecology and Their Associated Bioinformatic Analyses.

Changes / Problems
Nothing Reported

Training & Professional Development
James Borneman trained 3 Ph.D. students, 1 Project Scientist, 1 Junior Specialist, and 1 visiting scientist.

Dissemination Streams
Presentation by James Borneman: Metabolic Modeling and Microbe-Based Strategies to Manage HLB. Visit from Chinese Delegation from Various Universities and Institutes with Expertise in HLB. Meeting in Riverside CA, January 13, 2020. Presentation by James Borneman: Indigenous Populations of Dactylella oviparasitica Appear to Suppress Cyst Nematode Populations in Several Regions & Crops. Annual Meeting of Western Regional Project W-4147 on Biological Control, December 4 2020, Zoom because of COVID pandemic. James Borneman is a senior editor for the journal,Phytobiomes. James Borneman is a senior editor for the journal,PhytoFrontiers. James Borneman gave presentations to undergraduate and graduate students in his two Microbiomes courses (MCBL 126 & MCBL 226). These presentations covered biological suppression of plant parasitic nematodes as well as root microbes that may inhibit or exacerbate Huanglongbing disease of citrus.

Next Reporting Steps
OBJECTIVE 1. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Cyst Nematodes OBJECTIVE 1a. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils We will continue with the abovementioned research. We are in the process of isolating the putative beneficial organisms described above. We will then examine them by causality tests. OBJECTIVE 2. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Huanglongbing We will continue with the abovementioned research. We will also finish the citrus metabolic model, which will enable us to determine the nutrients needed to better maintain the health of HLB diseased citrus trees.

Outputs

Target Audience
This project has three interrelated objectives listed below.The target audiences for this project are (i) scientists endeavoring to perform similar studies targeting both similar and different pathogens, (ii) scientists performing molecular based studies that would benefit from the tools we have and are developing and (iii) stakeholders that could benefit from the solutions that are developed both directly and indirectly from our research.In addition, James Borneman integrates his research findings and related concepts into his undergraduate and graduate level microbiology courses, which he teaches every year: MCBL 126, an undergraduate microbiology course in microbiomes and MCBL 226, a graduate microbiology course in microbiomes. OBJECTIVE 1. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Cyst Nematodes OBJECTIVE 1a. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils OBJECTIVE 1b. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode OBJECTIVE 1c. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Soils Suppressive Against Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode OBJECTIVE 1d. Developing Cropping Decision Models that Enable the Creation of Maintenance of Soils that Suppress the Other Cyst Nematodes Including the Soybean Cyst Nematode OBJECTIVE 2. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Huanglongbing OBJECTIVE 2a. Create Peptides that Specifically Kill CLas with High Efficacy, and Test Them in Citrus by CTV Delivery and Engineered Plant Delivery OBJECTIVE 2b. Create and Utilize Metabolic Models of CLas, Citrus and ACP, and Their Interactions OBJECTIVE 2c. Identify Non-Pathogenic Microbes that Inhabit the Citrus Phloem, and Which Could be Used to Deliver Anti-CLas Agents to Manage Huanglongbing OBJECTIVE 3. Develop New Methods for Molecular Microbial Ecology and Their Associated Bioinformatic Analyses.

Changes / Problems
Nothing Reported

Training & Professional Development
James Borneman trained 3 Ph.D. students, 1 Project Scientist, 1 Junior Specialist, and 1 visiting scientist.

Dissemination Streams
Presentation by James Borneman titled "Microbiome Analyses of HLB Infected Citrus Trees." Annual Meeting of Western Regional Project W-3147 on Biological Control, November 30 2018, Azure Hotel, Ontario, CA. Presentation by James Borneman titled "Modeling the Interactions Between CLas, Citrus, and ACP for the Development of HLB Management Strategies." Fraunhofer Institute Visit Meeting in Riverside CA, January 11, 2019. Presentation by James Borneman titled " Use of Dactylella oviparasitica to Improve the Sugarbeet Cropping Decision Model." Sugarbeet Work Group Meeting, February 8 2019, Holtville CA. James Borneman integrates his research findings and related concepts into his undergraduate and graduate level microbiology courses, which he teaches every year: MCBL 126, an undergraduate microbiology course in microbiomes and MCBL 226, a graduate microbiology course in microbiomes.

Next Reporting Steps
OBJECTIVE 1. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Cyst Nematodes OBJECTIVE 1a. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils We will continue with the abovementioned research and perform similar experiments with soils cropped to sugar beets in the Imperial Valley of California. OBJECTIVE 2. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Huanglongbing We will continue with the abovementioned research. We will also finish the citrus metabolic model, which will enable us to determine the nutrients needed to better maintain the health of HLB diseased citrus trees. <br><br>

Impacts (unparsed)

<br>What was accomplished under these goals? OBJECTIVE 1. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Cyst Nematodes OBJECTIVE 1a. Determine the Interactions Among Crop Cultivars and the Indigenous Hyperparasite Dactylella oviparasitica Enabling Development of Sugarbeet Cyst Nematode Suppressive Soils We performed a study where the goal was to determine whether indigenous populations of the nematophagous fungus,Hyalorbilia oviparasitica(formerlyDactylella oviparasitica) and related fungi, were associated with suppression of the sugarbeet cyst nematode (Heterodera schachtii) in Californian soils previously cropped toBrassicaspecies. Experiments to determine the amount of biologicalH. schachtiisuppressiveness in these soils were performed by planting aH. schachtiihost crop in autoclaved and unautoclaved portions of each soil, infesting them withH. schachtii, and then counting the number ofH. schachtiifemales after two nematode generations. The amount of suppressiveness was calculated by dividing the number ofH. schachtiifemales per gram of fresh cabbage roots from the autoclaved soils by those from the unautoclaved soils. The relationship between the amounts ofH. schachtiisuppressiveness and the population densities ofH. oviparasiticaand related fungi was examined in two ways. These analyses showed that the four soils with the highest amounts of nematode suppressiveness also had the highest population densities of these fungi, and that there was a strong positive correlation between the levels ofH. schachtiisuppressiveness and these fungi across all of the tested soils. Our results suggest that members of theH. oviparasiticaClade, which are globally distributed, could be reducing the populations of several different cyst nematodes that detrimentally impact a wide variety of economically important crops. We expect that this research will lead to the development of new cropping decision models that will enable growers to be create and maintain soils that suppressH. schachtii, which we anticipate will lead to higher crop yields and profitability for the growers. We expect that this research will lead to the development of new methods - namely applying the beneficial fungus to field soils - that will enable growers to be create and maintain soils that suppressH. schachtii, which we anticipate will lead to higher crop yields and profitability for the growers. OBJECTIVE 2. Create New and Effective Strategies to Sustainably Manage Huanglongbing OBJECTIVE 2a. Create Peptides that Specifically Kill CLas with High Efficacy, and Test Them in Citrus by CTV Delivery and Engineered Plant Delivery This objective is to create targeted anti-CLas peptides that will be delivered to citrus phloem by an engineered citrus virus or engineered citrus. To date, we have selected for peptides that specifically bind to CLas. OBJECTIVE 2b. Create and Utilize Metabolic Models of CLas, Citrus and ACP, and Their Interactions This objective is tocreate anin silicometabolic model of the HLB pathosystem, which will enable a systems-biology-based understanding ofCLas, citrus and the Asian citrus psyllid, along with their interactions. This model will therefore provide researchers, engineers and agribusinesses with a powerful suite of tools and an unprecedented base of knowledge - which we expect will enable them to create (i) anti-CLas molecules, (ii) HLB-tolerant/resistant citrus (iii) early detection methods as well as (iv) media and conditions to cultivateCLasin vitro. To date, we have created the metabolic model for CLas - and that publication has been submitted. OBJECTIVE 2c. Identify Non-Pathogenic Microbes that Inhabit the Citrus Phloem, and Which Could be Used to Deliver Anti-CLas Agents to Manage Huanglongbing We have examined the bacteria and fungi of HLB survivor and non-survivor trees in Florida over the last four years. Survivor trees are those that have a very slow rate of decline. These studies determined that the most abundant bacteria and fungi in the survivor trees - which have a disease rating of 3 on a scale of 1 to 5 - have similar microbes to the healthiest trees (disease rating of 1) that have a normal and rapid rate of decline. We are in the process of isolating these organisms, which we will then examine by causality tests. <br><br><b>Publications</b><br>


Publications Inventory

Journal Articles